Clergy Who Served in the Second Church, 1890-1940
(P: pastor; A: assistant)
This list was maintained for many years by Lynn Marsh Freeman, and was updated in 2021 by Jerry Conlon and Kathleen Wiegand.
| Rev. Michael P. Sullivan | Sep. 1883-Jul. 1896 (A) |
| Rev. James R. Matthews | Jan. 1887-1890 (A) |
| Rt. Rev. James M. O’Brien | Apr. 1888-Dec. 1922 (P) |
| Rev. Thomas J. Monteverde | Jul. 1890-Apr. 1892 (A) |
| Rev. Martin O’Donoghue | 1896-1899 (A) |
| Rev. Philip McGuire | Jan. 1896-Feb. 1902 (A) |
| Rev. John L. Sullivan | Jul. 1899-Apr. 1901 (A) |
| Rev. Joseph S. Gallen | Apr. 1901-Aug. 1906 (A) |
| Rev. John Dowling | Feb. 1902-Ju1. 1904 (A) |
| Rev. Hugh A. Curley | Sep. 1904-Apr. 1914 (A) |
| Rev. Stephen T. Morris | Jan. 1907-Aug. 1923 (A) |
| Rev. J. L. Weidenhan | Apr. 1914-Jun. 1922 (A) |
| Rev. M. O’Donoghue | Feb. 1914 (A) |
| Nov. 1921 (A) | |
| Jul. 1922 (A) | |
| Rev. John J. Corbett | Jun. 1922-Oct. 1924 (A) |
| Rev. Thomas A. Calnan | Jan. 1923 (A) |
| Rt. Rev. Eugene J. Connelly | Dec. 1922-May 1942 (P) |
| Rev. John Carroll Moore | Sep. 1923-Feb. 1926 (A) |
| Rev. Thomas A. Brennan | Nov. 1924-Nov. 1925 (A) |
| Rev. J. W. Daily | Dec. 1925-Nov. 1926 (A) |
| Rev. Arthur W. Murphy | Mar. 1926-Ju1. 1926 (A) |
| Rev. J. C. Murphy | Mar. 1926-Jun. 1936 (A) |
| Rev. Paul L. Norris | Aug. 1926-Dec. 1940 (A) |
| Rev. Charles L. Boehmer | Oct. 1935-Jun. 1937 (A) |
| Rev. Charles W. Nelson | Jul. 1936-Sep. 1950 (A) |
| Rev. E. E. Sullivan | Jul. 1937-Feb. 1942 (A) |
| Rev. E. P. Kearney | Feb. 1940-Jun. 1940 (A) |
| Rev. Martin W. Hyland | Jun. 1940-Sep. 1952 (A) |
Rt. Rev. James M. O’Brien, pastor 1888-1922, in undated photo; he built the second church and led centennial celebrations in 1920

Rev. Philip McGuire, assistant 1896-1902, in 1900 photo

Rt. Rev. Eugene J. Connelly, pastor 1922-1942, in undated photo; he built the third church after the catastrophic fire in 1940